Makes it unlawful for an employer in New York to use or implement an automated decision tool to filter employment candidates or prospective candidates for hire that has not undergone a disparate impact assessment annually.
Makes it unlawful for an employer in New York to use or implement an automated decision tool to filter employment candidates or prospective candidates for hire that has not undergone an disparate impact assessment annually.
Requires employers to provide the department with a summary of their most recent disparate impact analysis annually. Allows the Attorney General and Commissioner to initiate investigations and legal action if violations are suspected or found. Requires a summary of the most recent disparate impact analysis of the automated decision tool and the distribution date of the tool to be made publicly available on the website of the employer prior to implementing the tool.
This summary is awaiting validation (peer review by a second AGORA editor).
This document has not been enacted or otherwise finalized and is subject to change. This summary is based on a copy of the document collected 2024-10-04 - refer to the official source for the most current version.
Key facts
🏛️ This document has been proposed by the State of New York, but is not yet enacted.
For authoritative text and metadata, visit the official source.
🎯 This document primarily applies to the private sector, rather than the government.
📜 This document's name is An act to amend the labor law, in relation to establishing criteria for
the use of automated employment decision tools.
AGORA also tracks this document under the name Automated Employment Decision Tools Amendment to NY Labor Law.
Themes
AI risks, applications, governance strategies, and other themes addressed in AGORA documents.
Thematic tags for this document are awaiting validation (peer review by a second AGORA editor).
This document has not been enacted or otherwise finalized and is subject to change. This summary is based on a copy of the document collected 2024-10-04 - refer to the official source for the most current version.
This tag applies to documents addressing instances where AI is implicated in differential treatment based on protected characteristics, such as race, gender, sex, pregnancy, and disability. Differential treatment based upon protected characteristics often overlaps or occurs with a civil rights violation.
This tag applies to documents addressing AI-related violations of human rights, civil liberties, civil rights, or democratic norms and systems. Examples include censorship, invasion of privacy, loss of access to government services or benefits, and racial discrimination.
This tag applies to documents that require, encourage, etc. the disclosure of information about AI systems by their users, developers, vendors, or others directly involved with the systems to third parties, including but not limited to the general public.
This tag applies to documents that address disclosure of whether and how an AI system is deployed; for example, requiring users of government services to be notified when AI systems are used to determine how the services are provided.
This tag applies to documents that require, encourage, etc. the systematic evaluation of AI systems, or of broader systems or processes into which AI is directly integrated.
This is an unofficial copy. The document has been
archived and reformatted in plaintext for AGORA. Footnotes, tables, and
similar material may be omitted. For the official text, visit the original source.
Thematic tags for this document are awaiting validation (peer review by a second AGORA editor).
This text may be out of date. According to the latest data in AGORA,
this document has been proposed, but is not yet enacted or otherwise
finalized. This text was collected 2024-10-04 and
may have been revised in the meantime. Visit the official source for authoritative text.
AN ACT to amend the labor law, in relation to establishing criteria for
the use of automated employment decision tools
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM-
BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS:
Section 1. The labor law is amended by adding a new section 203-f to
read as follows:
§ 203-F. USE OF AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOLS. 1. FOR PURPOSES
OF THIS SECTION, THE FOLLOWING TERMS SHALL HAVE THE FOLLOWING MEANINGS:
Amends labor law, establishes criteria for using automated employment decision tools in New York.
Amends labor law, establishes criteria for using automated employment decision tools in New York.
A. "AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOL" MEANS ANY SYSTEM USED TO
FILTER EMPLOYMENT CANDIDATES OR PROSPECTIVE CANDIDATES FOR HIRE IN A WAY
THAT ESTABLISHES A PREFERRED CANDIDATE OR CANDIDATES WITHOUT RELYING ON
CANDIDATE-SPECIFIC ASSESSMENTS BY INDIVIDUAL DECISION-MAKERS. AUTOMATED
EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOLS SHALL INCLUDE PERSONALITY TESTS, COGNITIVE
ABILITY TESTS, RESUME SCORING SYSTEMS AND ANY SYSTEM WHOSE FUNCTION IS
GOVERNED BY STATISTICAL THEORY, OR WHOSE PARAMETERS ARE DEFINED BY SUCH
SYSTEMS, INCLUDING INFERENTIAL METHODOLOGIES, LINEAR REGRESSION, NEURAL
NETWORKS, DECISION TREES, RANDOM FORESTS AND OTHER ARTIFICIAL INTELLI-
GENCE OR MACHINE LEARNING ALGORITHMS. THE TERM "AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT
DECISION TOOL" DOES NOT INCLUDE A TOOL THAT DOES NOT AUTOMATE, SUPPORT,
SUBSTANTIALLY ASSIST OR REPLACE DISCRETIONARY DECISION-MAKING PROCESSES
AND THAT DOES NOT MATERIALLY IMPACT NATURAL PERSONS.
B. "DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS" MEANS AN IMPARTIAL ANALYSIS, INCLUDING
BUT NOT LIMITED TO TESTING OF THE EXTENT TO WHICH USE OF AN AUTOMATED
EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOL IS LIKELY TO RESULT IN AN ADVERSE IMPACT TO THE
DETRIMENT OF ANY GROUP ON THE BASIS OF SEX, RACE, ETHNICITY, OR OTHER
PROTECTED CLASS UNDER ARTICLE FIFTEEN OF THE EXECUTIVE LAW. THE RESULTS
OF SUCH ANALYSIS SHALL BE REPORTED TO THE EMPLOYER IMPLEMENTING OR USING
AN AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOL. A DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS
SHALL DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN CANDIDATES WHO WERE SELECTED AND CANDIDATES
WHO WERE NOT SELECTED BY THE TOOL AND SHALL INCLUDE A DISPARATE IMPACT
ANALYSIS AS SPECIFIED IN THE UNIFORM GUIDELINES ON EMPLOYEE SELECTION
PROCEDURES PROMULGATED BY THE UNITED STATES EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY
COMMISSION.
C. "EMPLOYMENT DECISION" MEANS TO SCREEN CANDIDATES FOR EMPLOYMENT.
Defines "Automated Employment Decision Tool" as AI systems filtering candidates without individual assessments.
Defines "Automated Employment Decision Tool" as AI systems filtering candidates without individual assessments.
2. IT SHALL BE UNLAWFUL FOR AN EMPLOYER TO IMPLEMENT OR USE AN AUTO-
MATED EMPLOYMENT DECISION TOOL THAT FAILS TO COMPLY WITH THE FOLLOWING
PROVISIONS:
A. NO LESS THAN ANNUALLY, A DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS SHALL BE
CONDUCTED TO ASSESS THE ACTUAL IMPACT OF ANY AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT
DECISION TOOL USED BY ANY EMPLOYER TO SELECT CANDIDATES FOR JOBS WITHIN
THE STATE. SUCH DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS SHALL BE PROVIDED TO THE
EMPLOYER BUT SHALL NOT BE PUBLICLY FILED AND SHALL BE SUBJECT TO ALL
APPLICABLE PRIVILEGES.
B. A SUMMARY OF THE MOST RECENT DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS OF SUCH TOOL
AS WELL AS THE DISTRIBUTION DATE OF THE TOOL TO WHICH THE ANALYSIS
APPLIES HAS BEEN MADE PUBLICLY AVAILABLE ON THE WEBSITE OF THE EMPLOYER
OR EMPLOYMENT AGENCY PRIOR TO THE IMPLEMENTATION OR USE OF SUCH TOOL.
C. NO LESS THAN ANNUALLY, ANY EMPLOYER USING AN AUTOMATED EMPLOYMENT
DECISION TOOL SHALL PROVIDE TO THE DEPARTMENT SUCH SUMMARY OF THE MOST
RECENT DISPARATE IMPACT ANALYSIS PROVIDED TO THE EMPLOYER ON THAT TOOL.
Prohibits employers from using non-compliant automated employment tools; requires annual disparate impact analysis and public summaries.
Prohibits employers from using non-compliant automated employment tools; requires annual disparate impact analysis and public summaries.
3. THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY INITIATE AN INVESTIGATION IF A PREPONDER-
ANCE OF THE EVIDENCE, INCLUDING THE SUMMARY OF THE MOST RECENT DISPA-
RATE IMPACT ANALYSIS ESTABLISHES A SUSPICION OF A VIOLATION. THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY ALSO INITIATE IN ANY COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDIC-
TION ANY ACTION OR PROCEEDING THAT MAY BE APPROPRIATE OR NECESSARY FOR
CORRECTION OF ANY VIOLATION ISSUED PURSUANT THIS SECTION, INCLUDING
MANDATING COMPLIANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION OR SUCH OTHER
RELIEF AS MAY BE APPROPRIATE.
Authorizes the Attorney General to investigate and initiate actions for correcting suspected violations.
Authorizes the Attorney General to investigate and initiate actions for correcting suspected violations.
4. THE COMMISSIONER MAY INITIATE AN INVESTIGATION IF A PREPONDERANCE
OF THE EVIDENCE, INCLUDING THE SUMMARY OF THE MOST RECENT DISPARATE
IMPACT ANALYSIS ESTABLISHES A SUSPICION OF A VIOLATION. THE COMMISSION-
ER MAY ALSO INITIATE IN A COURT OF COMPETENT JURISDICTION ANY ACTION OR
PROCEEDING THAT MAY BE APPROPRIATE OR NECESSARY FOR THE CORRECTION OF
ANY VIOLATION ISSUED PURSUANT TO THIS SECTION, INCLUDING MANDATING
COMPLIANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF THIS SECTION OR SUCH OTHER RELIEF AS
MAY BE APPROPRIATE.
5. THE DEPARTMENT MAY PROMULGATE RULES AND REGULATIONS AS IT DEEMS
NECESSARY TO EFFECTUATE THE PURPOSES OF THIS SECTION, ON OR BEFORE SUCH
EFFECTIVE DATE.
§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
Allows the commissioner to initiate investigations and legal actions based on evidence of violations.
Allows the commissioner to initiate investigations and legal actions based on evidence of violations.